Skip to main content

Residents Ask: "What is the Problem?" and "Will Cityhood Fix It?"

Reasonable people, like Ed Ewing from the Amberwood
neighborhood, have serious questions about the methods
by which city advocacy groups determined that there was
an actual, real problem identified that cities will now fix.

If you share this and other concerns, please show up to
vote No on Nov. 3.  The city groups have a lot of people
convinced that a city will help them.  There must be enough
skeptics willing to show up and vote no or else we will
all find out the hard way that neither Lavista Hills
NOR Tucker  will be viable cities without raising our taxes. 
In reviewing the public comments portions of the Tucker, Lakeside and Briarcliff meetings before the House of Representatives back in 2014, we found some speakers who made some excellent points (and others who didn't make much sense to us at all.)  

We'll post some of those transcribed comments here and others we will post on our YouTube channel in case you want to catch up with all the things that happened as our Central DeKalb communities were faced with the issue of a cityhood referendum.

So, first, we give you the comments from a resident who found himself in the boundaries of both the Lakeside and Briarcliff maps (which were pretty close to identical except for Briarcliff wishing to take the Emory campus and take the city limits right to the borders of existing cities of Decatur and Avondale Estates.

Here is Ed Ewing from the "Amberwood" neighborhood inside the perimeter of 285, what's now being claimed by "Lavista Hills" and slated for a vote, along with the Tucker city vote, on your ballots this November 3, 2015.

Good afternoon.  I'm Ed Ewing from Amberwood.
 What is the problem?   
And would cityhood be the solution? 
Everyone knows there have been problems in DeKalb County.  But has anyone comprehensively defined the problem beyond a mere collection of anecdotes?  
No, the organizers are relying on "impressions."  A systematic, quantitative study would supposedly be "too expensive."
These are all smart, experienced, likable, earnest people but they are manifesting the all too common human tendency to rush to solutions instead of taking on the hard, unglamorous work of defining problems.  
What does a positive $30,000 feasibility study prove?  A financial feasibility study should not be confused with a viable, strategic plan, which does not exist at this time.   
To some, "plan" is a four letter word.  What do the 63,000 citizens in the proposed cityhood area really want?  LCA organizers have diligently counted all the community meetings they have held: some 75 or more, they claim.  But, have they actually conducted any polls, sampling the meeting attendees let alone the population at large? 
No, they are relying upon "impressions."
A political poll would be too expensive, they claim.  So, how many Facebook "likes" do they have?  600 something.  About 1% of the target population. 
In other words, 99% of the 63,000 citizens have NOT liked LCA on LCA's own Facebook page.
I'm afraid this attempt at "empire building" is all about what LCA wants.   
Vote no on Lakeside cityhood.  (now known as "Lavista Hills.")

Note:  The original person who requested that Senator Millar sponsor a bill to form a "Lakeside City" in DeKalb County was Steve Schultz, a community organizer who has his own, very successful political consultancy business.  This business, called Rosetta Stone, is notorious for making "robo calls" on behalf of their clients.  So, while it might be too expensive for the average person to make a call to every resident in the proposed area with a question or two about cityhood, for Schultz and Rosetta Stone, it would literally be just another day at the office. And yet they didn't do it.

Why?  Because this effort to form cities has never been about caring about what the citizens think.

Do you really think they are going to suddenly start caring now?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Tweak us out of LaVista Hills

This is a letter shared with the "Dekalb Strong" group.  You can join the conversation at https://www.facebook.com/groups/DeKalbStrong . We didn't realize how easy tweaking was. “Tweak” and just like that, 2000 people are moved from one city proposal to another. (“LaVista Hills, Tucker border tweaked in Senate,” News, March 20). Our home is in Toco Hills on the southern edge of the proposed LaVista Hills and we’d like to be tweaked out of it.   North and north central DeKalb County residents have become pawns in the misguided ambitions of a few. With all the changes made by the Senate and House, it’s vital the feasibility of these proposals be revisited. The LaVista Hills boundaries have bled commercial property to the Tucker proposal and Brookhaven’s annexation of Executive Park. As reconfigured, LaVista Hills is almost entirely residential. Even including Toco Hills shopping center and Northlake mall, there appears to be insufficient commercial or ind...

DeKalb County School Board Member's Emails Show Support for Annexation

Here are just a few highlights of this investigative piece that was reported by Jeff Chirico, CBS Atlanta. Marshall Orson, a seated board member in DeKalb County, has to answer to some angry parents about his emails with supporters for "Together in Atlanta," a group pushing for annexation into the city of Atlanta. The annexation would take a DeKalb icon, the Druid Hills High School, and at least two elementary schools into the city limits of Atlanta, while still the residents would still technically reside in DeKalb County.  The Fernbank Science Center and Museum, Callenwalde Fine Arts Center and other parts of DeKalb County would also become new residents of "Atlanta in DeKalb."   State Rep. Karla Drenner (D - Avondale Estates) says she is shocked to learn that a school board member would seemingly favor something that could 'decimate' the school system. Annexation opponent Dawn Forman said Orson, as an elected board member, should be opposed t...

Do These Families Feel "Welcomed" at DeKalb County's Schools?

Georgia counties where 50 or more unaccompanied minors were released from Jan. 1 through July, according to the Office of Refugee Resettlement in the U.S. Dept. of Health & Human Services Administration for Children & Families. Cherokee County 65 Cobb County 138 DeKalb County 347 Fulton County 64 Gwinnett County 266 Hall County 85 WHO knows the truth about what is happening in our schools and how quickly are they acting to protect their own neighborhoods, drawing their own borders and leaving everyone else holding the education tab for the immigrant population THEY helped bring here?    Do the new city proponents claim to know anything about a city - school connection?  Or do they do the typical  political  double speak and merely deny, deny, deny?  WHAT do they know that they are not telling the rest of us?  WHO do they know and HOW will they benefit?  If you do not know the answers then you are probably on the losing end of...