Skip to main content

Brookhaven City Councilman Warns DeKalb County Residents about What Lies Ahead


Jim Eyre, the first ever elected councilman for Brookhaven who later resigned and stepped down from his seat on the council, warns DeKalb County residents about what could lay ahead for them if they approve new cities.You can watch and listen to his speech,  already cued up for you, here.

Jim Eyre warns Tucker and Lavista Hills area residents
about the short-shortsightedness of new cities.
Here are the highlights of his speech:

1.  Yes, it is a new layer of bureaucracy stacked on top of the one we already have.
2.  There is no independent ethics board.  It is all handled through the city's attorney and the city council itself.  The potential offenders are the same ones overseeing the ethics.
3.  Confusing - who to call for various services.  It is another layer for everyone to hassle with.  It is intertwined with the county services and providers.  Are the services being provided in such a manner that adding this new layer is worth it?  In most cases, the cities are having to turn to DeKalb to provide the services anyway.
4.  Fast moving city council is pushing things so fast that people don't know what is going on.  The people are now paying for things they never wanted in the first place.  The projects are decided by the council members, not based on what the people want.
5.   Public / Private business model.  Very expensive.  They are paying 200 - 250 percent MORE for services than they would have paid if they kept it in house.
6.  Vendors - luck of the draw. Some are good; some not. Planning and Zoning is most poorly staffed and has cost the city a lot due to improper zoning and lawsuits.
7.   There is no vision for the city.  Mayor telling staff just approve whatever you can and that's how things are getting done.
8.  You need to read your city charter.  Most of the cities were set up as Weak Form Mayor.  Mayor proposes; council approves.  But what we have learned is that the Mayor gets to populate all the positions and the council is expected to just approve like a rubber stamp. So, the mayor has a lot of power.  Do you know who your Mayor will be?  If not, how will you control that power?
9. HOST Credit lowers your taxes by as much as 50%. That all goes away.  If you look how the cities will tax you, I think you are looking at higher taxes.  But, the more cities that are formed, the smaller everyone's cut will be from this "HOST" sales tax dollars.  But, even if you get a decent amount, HOST may go away in a few years.
10.  You will be paying additional franchise fees.  You will be paying about $70 more PER PERSON in your home just for the access to the same utilities you have in your home right now already.
11.  Look closely at your districts.  How are they established.  By law, they must be based on population but they don't have to look at concentration of voters.  If your districts are drawn in a way that gives most of the voters to a single district (like we have in District 1 for Brookhaven) then you have an unbalanced power structure.
12.  You want to get away from the North /South divide in DeKalb County, but we have the exact same thing in Brookhaven.  There are dividing lines in the community and that's how the money will be spent. You will be on one side or the other of the lines, but it will make things difficult.
13.  Look at all the people who are supporting the city efforts right now on the pro-city team because those are the people who will most likely be running your city, sitting on your boards.  If you don't like what you see, maybe it isn't the right time for your city.

Full meeting recorded below.  It was held by DeKalb Strong on May 14, 2015.


Popular posts from this blog

Welcome to Smoke Rise, Soon to be Tucker, GA

The driving force behind the city of Tucker has been the leadership within the community known as "Smoke Rise, GA."  Smoke Rise residents currently have addresses that say "Stone Mountain, GA" and many of them worked hard in order to create a separate identity for themselves, petitioning the U.S. Post Office to change their official name to "Smoke Rise."  While the Post Office did not agree to change the official name, they did agree to allow "Smoke Rise" as a recognized alternative to "Stone Mountain" that could be used interchangeably as long as it accompanied their 30087 zip code.

It is important to note that these residents did not ask the Post Office to recognize their use of "Tucker" as an acceptable alternative.  They asked to be called "Smoke Rise."

It appears that zip codes and address labels are important to them, just as our Tucker zip code is important to us.  And, while we do understand that Smoke Rise…

Tucker Behaving Badly

Newly elected Tucker Mayor Frank Auman (center) and four council-members were sworn in to their positions on March 8 at Tucker High School.  The council members represented exactly 2 of the 3 districts.  Despite the fact that they were not bound by any particular charter requirement to do so, they decided to move forward without the conclusion of District 2's election, which was held over by the need for a runoff.

When met with objections, they promptly began holding meetings anyway.  And they hired staff members, specifically lawyers, more specifically lawyers who are experts in election laws and understanding the charter. 

The seats for District 2 were decided in a runoff election March 29. And April 1, the results were deemed finalized by the Elections Supervisor in DeKalb County.  A separate swearing in ceremony was held at Tucker Recreation Center for them.

When Auman was elected mayor, he said his first goal is to build a foundation for the city.
“We have to get the rev…

Tucker Township? A Vision or a Pipe Dream?

Who drew this map?  We are not really sure.  We stumbled upon it recently while looking for Tucker election results. We do, however, think this map, called "Tucker Township" actually shows a good compromise between Tucker and Lavista Hills that could have worked well for everyone.   It offers a great way to share the Northlake area commercial tax revenue.  So, why didn't anyone suggest something like this  prior to putting forth competing bills in the 2013 and 2014 legislative sessions?  And, why is Tucker's city still being allowed to move forward when it has been called "unconstitutional" by even the legislators who supported it?
Limited services government in the form of a new city is something that the Georgia constitution does not allow, apparently.  But, unless citizens decide to fight the creation of Tucker or Peachtree Corners, two of such limited cities are going to continue operating until someone tells them that they cannot.  
Save Tucker…